I use NYC foundation and Eye Shimmer Dust in opal along with E.L.F. lip stain and waterproof mascara. I do actually like the NYC foundation, given it’s cheap. First I use Garnier’s Dark Circle Roller and blend with an E.L.F. Flawless Concealer Brush, then I apply the foundation with a Mac foundation brush, and apply and blend out the eye dust with a Mac eyeshadow brush (I find the bottle applicator is messy and causes fallout). Set with powder, then apply mascara. Here’s the finished look with Circle Lenses:
I do prefer Philosophy’s The Supernatural, it’s what I use on shoots but I tanned this summer and tried NYC, L’Oreal’s liquid powder foundation, and Maybelline’s Fit Me (Which I hated: clogged pores).